Jamie Nelson is a talented photographer. Apparently, BBDO liked her work so much, they wanted to use it. Problem is, I guess, they didn’t want to pay for it so they got another photographer to recreate one of her images.
This isn’t even close to being a questionable case–it’s totally an infringement and I hope she goes after them (including the other photographer!) with a great lawyer.
Of course, I assume that a pro like her is registering all her images… and that you are registering yours too. Right? Don’t make me come back there and beat you. 😉
There is another thing you can do to help prevent copyright infringement. When a client comes to you with an image (not a marker comp or other non-infringing comp) tell them that you can’t shoot it. Tell them that no mater how much or little you change, you (and they) could get sued for copyright. Let them know that there is NO acceptable percentage of change to save you–that is, the law does not cite a percentage. If reasonable people (a jury or even one judge, depending) would think that the images are too alike, that’s all it takes.
And go after the photographers, not just the clients, who rip off your work.
(hat tip to åsk for the link)